Views
Time to reload Big Brother 10
The show needs a revamp - and it needs a revamp now
time-to-reload-big-brother-10

It’s seven days since my last blog, and hence seven days since I gave up watching the nightly highlights - after ten years of not missing a single episode.

I’m still roughly aware of the main events of the week, such as the not exactly mind-blowing tasks, and Big Brother proving just when you think things can’t get any worse, they have Vanessa Feltz and Iain Lee - on the same show!

Anyhow, enough moaning - this blog is intended to be a bit more positive.

And by that I mean it’s time the producers took some positive action - if they act within the next week, they have a change of rescuing something out of the mess that is BB10 and lift the ratings from around the 2m mark back towards the heady heights of nearer 3m.

How, I hear you ask?

Well, desperate times call for desperate measures so nothing should be ruled out.    Let’s first take a look at what other countries have done mid-season when viewers have turned away from Big Brother, with varying degrees of success.

Evict Half the Housemates

The sixth season in Belgium was at a ratings low, so on Day 23 they announced half the housemates would be evicted.   The housemates were split into two groups, with viewers voting for which group to evict.   On Day 27 the “Big Exit” took place and six replacements were sent in, including two moles.

In the end it didn’t work out - there has only been one celebrity series since - but at least they tried something.

New (yet old) nominations

Not the best example, as BB Australia actually did give their final series the overhaul it had been waiting for.    However, it didn’t boost the ratings as the network would have liked, so a few weeks in they admitted their new nomination format (with the viewers nominating, housemates evicting) wasn’t working, so introduced a “new” format - which seemed remarkably similar to the format used in the seven years previously, with housemates nominating and viewers evicting.

In the end it didn’t save the show from the axe, but it was enough to make it feel like Big Brother again - after a first few weeks where for many, it didn’t.

Big Brother - Reloaded

Not all revamps lead to the axe, and for Big Brother Germany, a very public relaunch helped the show recover from a poor start in the ratings.  With the show running for a lengthy seven months, the producers took action just one month into the latest series - and made a lot of noise about the changes they would make.

The theme tune was changed, the show was rebranded “Big Brother Reloaded”, and whilst housemates were locked in the task rooms for a weekend, the house itself even had a makeover.    The rules surrounding their Heaven and Hell divide were changed so that Hell would primarily be home only to the nominees and any rule breakers, while three “All Stars” - popular housemates from previous series - entered the house as fully fledged contestants.

And although these mid-season revamps had mixed success, it’s clear that it’s better to try something than to try nothing at all.

Indeed even Big Brother UK has usually had a trick up their sleeve in previous series to give the series a boost after the initial interest calms down, with twists such as the Secret Garden, the House Next Door and even BB8’s “Fake Week”.

So what can producers do to rescue this series of Big Brother?

Well, stay tuned to find out.

Written by Brekkie Posted on Day 17 at 9:39pm Share/bookmark this post:
  • Facebook
  • MySpace
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Live
  • TwitThis
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
Link to this story:
40 comments
Steve’Lee says: June 20, 2009 @ 9:51 pm

Yes Brekkie, but with all theese revamps they fail! Surely just leave it while its attracting a few million viewers compared to getting axed?

Ivan says: June 20, 2009 @ 9:56 pm

Brekkie your so negative, just get over yourself!

All your negative columns are really irritating and are starting to get boring. I’m really fed up of them and I’m sure I’m not the only one.

Brekkie says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:03 pm

Yet you still read them.

This is a two-parter. The second will be looking at what they could do.

lanky says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:03 pm

Ivan, if you’d bothered to read his article you’d have realised it’s not negative and it’s looking at ways Big Brother can be saved.

Stu says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:08 pm

Maybe are just witnessing the end. I think I heard once that C4 are desperate to get out of the contract with Endemol, that’s probably why their makeing such a hash of this series.

Ivan says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:11 pm

Actually, All I had to do was read the title and I knew what was coming.

Your kind of predictable too Brekkie. I mean, how many articles have you posted about the good things about Big Brother?

lanky says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:17 pm

Only problem is Ivan, this is one of Brekkie’s more positive articles which actually contains little opinion.

In future I suggest you don’t judge posts by their titles…

Ivan says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:20 pm

OK, so the title never has anything to do with the article at all? Whatever ya say…

Quote: “..just when you think things can’t get any worse, they have Vanessa Feltz and Iain Lee - on the same show!”

?

Brekkie says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:29 pm

Go on Ivan - list five positives about Vanessa Feltz and Iain Lee.

Dare you.

lanky says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:31 pm

I didn’t mean that. I meant that you automatically judged it to be a negative article from the title when it is positive on the whole.

And you appear to have missed the line straight afterwards, which Brekkie has even placed in bold: “Anyhow, enough moaning - this blog is intended to be a bit more positive.”

Which it is.

Ivan says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:34 pm

First of all, you said the show needed a revamp. Not posotove thinking.

No I wont. Wanna know why? Because you wouldn’t be able too. YOU do it. You can’t make me do anything.

Ivan says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:34 pm

*positive

lanky says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:38 pm

How is it not positive thinking to want a show that has lost 1million viewers (that’s 40% of the audience from last year) to have a revamp? :S

Brekkie says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:40 pm

Well, to be fair Ivan my challenge was impossible.

Ivan says: June 20, 2009 @ 10:45 pm

If people dont want to watch it then let them off!

Theres loads of positives!:
- This year’s housemates are the best in a few years IMHO.
- I love this year’s house.
- I love the new Evicition Interview studio.
- This years titles are pretty cool aswell.

Yeah, it suddenly becomes impossible when you are told to do it.

Jonny Boy says: June 20, 2009 @ 11:25 pm

God Ivan!
How immature are you!
This is a fan site, if you dont like it, then don’t come back!!
You should be thanking Brekkie and the team, for keeping their eyes open for Big Brother gossip and displaying it on here! If you don’t like their opinions and negativity and positivity (which everyone has entitled to)then do one !! Because us fans, cant be bothered reading, your petty stupid quotes that you come up with! Same goes for anyone, who wants to be immature and fight about silly things!
Child!

Jonny Boy says: June 20, 2009 @ 11:27 pm

P.s
You obviously haven’t realized, you the one who is irritating =]

Lewis [*-*] says: June 20, 2009 @ 11:29 pm

I agree with Ivan, they have done a load of good things this year, its just two “Bad” things that are big that we think of more. Like Ivan has already said, These are some of the best housemates yet, the house is fantastic, the eviction studio is the best ever imo (the interview format however isn’t), the eye is very unique (new), the small but effective stage outside the house is good, the titles are OK, the build up I thought was fine

Think positive and quit with the small sulking “Anyhow, enough moaning - this blog is intended to be a bit more positive.

And by that I mean it’s time the producers took some positive action” side-notes.

Lewis [*-*] says: June 20, 2009 @ 11:30 pm

* by the way I am not moaning at you, my post does seem a bit rude, im just saying it would be nice to take a look at all of the great things and block out the side-notes :)!

Ivan says: June 20, 2009 @ 11:38 pm

Thank you Lewis! Thats all I’m trying to say!

Ivan says: June 20, 2009 @ 11:41 pm

..oh and johhny, if you cant be bothered reading my quotes then how were you able to comment on them?

You know I do actually love this site, it’s great and I am thankful for Matt and Brekkie for giving us this exclusive info but I’m just saying that they are focusing too much on all the “negative” stuff!

Brekkie says: June 20, 2009 @ 11:59 pm

There is little point in having a views section though if we can’t post our own views - and most of our views are often on one topic or area, and the issue of the show needing to relaunch has been discussed quite a bit in various places:

Quoting Lewis:
“These are some of the best housemates yet, the house is fantastic, the eviction studio is the best ever imo (the interview format however isn’t), the eye is very unique (new), the small but effective stage outside the house is good, the titles are OK, the build up I thought was fine”

I actually agree with a lot of that. OK, wouldn’t say they’re the best housemates in a while, but I do think (though from secondary opinion as I’ve skipped the show for a week) they’re better HMs than initially expected. I wouldn’t say the house is fantastic either - but it’s only really the bedroom and kitchen letting it down.

Studio and stage completely agree with, the eye has grown on me, the titles are OK - but the build up - well, what build up is what I’d say.

Anyhow though, that’s about as positive as I get about BB10 - doesn’t make great reading does it.

I never expect everyone to agree with me, but that’s the reason we have comments - for people to state if they agree or not, and why.

For many the show itself may not need changes, but something clearly has to be done about the ratings - and if C4 cared about Big Brother they’d have pushed the panic button in week one.

However, now they’re more concerned about nabbing the Premier League rights off Setanta - despite claiming they’re skint!

BBFan says: June 21, 2009 @ 12:00 am

We’re 10 years into Big Brother, so why not rehash an old twist, complete with ex housemates? I’m thinking Bedsit/Secret Garden/HND. Those three twists could easily be merged to create the ultimate twist, and if they send in past favourites as fully fledged housemates then it could work. Pass that off as “Big Brothers 10th Birthday Celebrations” to save embarrassment of having to do a full scale relaunch. It won’t be popular online but it could work for the rest of the public.

Josh says: June 21, 2009 @ 12:07 am

Honestly, I think Brekkie makes good points. Not all revamps are bad. Just take the USA edition for example.

BB1 USA followed the same format as the first Netherlands edition (BBUK modified the format for their first series). Needless to say the original format didn’t go over well in the States.

After BB1 USA proved to be an utter flop CBS considered axing it. In an interview with the head of CBS he stated “if the product can be fixed there will be a Big Brother 2.”

After the nomination/eviction format was re-tooled and introduction of weekly eviction shows BB2 USA proved to be a success. Resulting in the USA version being renewed year after year.

The only USA season to perform as badly as BB1 USA was BB9 USA. BB10 USA managed to bring back viewers that BB9 USA lost by going back to basics re-introducing elements from the first three series that hadn’t been seen in recent versions (no twists, live audiences).

And while some put down the USA version due to its modified eviction format keep in mind Brazil adopted several aspects that originated in the USA version into their own.

BB Africa introduced their own take on the HoH and in their upcoming fourth season will allow housemates to discuss the nomination process freely allowing alliances to form, similar to the USA version.

Also the live feeds have been an important part in the USA show. This year CBS/RealNetworks have re-vamped the enter live feed interface for BB11 USA.

Brekkie says: June 21, 2009 @ 12:21 am

I guess some would argue BB9 USA is another example if a mid-season revamp, ditching the couples and switching back to individuals.

However, personally I thought that was always the intention, but even so, the show did pick up when the change was made.

Steve’Lee says: June 21, 2009 @ 10:11 am

I agree that Big Brother needs a reload. After all 10 years of the same format really does get boring after a time…

Chris says: June 21, 2009 @ 3:03 pm

OMG, they should have the public vote for nominations, and the housemates have to choose who they want to evict - I would LOVE to watch that :)

Dodge says: June 21, 2009 @ 3:31 pm

I don’t think there is any desire for a revamp from the broadcaster. And there won’t be any money in the kitty for a house revamp. All we will get are the usual rejects from the auditions sent in as new housemates at halftime.

Brekkie says: June 21, 2009 @ 3:38 pm

Chris - they’ve done that a few times and it does work well for the live show itself. The problem is though when done regularly it removes a key storyline from the daily shows - how the nominees react to being put up for eviction by their fellow HMs, and that is where BB Aus fell apart.

Must say though, I’m struggling with my second blog to come up with ideas on exactly how to revamp things - it’s much more difficult to do mid-series than it would have been to do from the start, where you can design the house around any twists.

So all suggestions welcome.

Michael says: June 21, 2009 @ 5:19 pm

Brekkie, (I haven’t looked at the other comments BTW) but I think you are being a complete fool to not watch this series, it was actually been pretty damn funny and entertaining to watch

I’m not going to say get over live feed or anything, but still watch even if there is no live feed
Secondly, no matter what twists the producers pull they will never ever be good enough to fulfill you as BB has ran so long new twists are nearly impossible

Brekkie says: June 21, 2009 @ 8:01 pm

Nearly impossible, but not quite Michael.

To be fair I’ve heard that the basic housemate interaction has been pretty good this week, but for me it’s always been more about the show than the housemates - and the format at the moment is too weak too engage me, with too many problems putting me off.

Also the tasks are absolutely the bread and butter of any series of Big Brother, and good tasks can carry a poor series. Until the producers realise though HMs dressing in costumes does not constitute entertaining TV they’ve got little chance of winning me back.

I know it’s easy to look back and mock tasks such as keeping a fire alive for a few days, but the truth is tasks like that revealed far more about the HMs than them doing something humiliating for a couple of hours ever would.

Stu says: June 21, 2009 @ 9:03 pm

Anyone else think that C4 are ‘dumbing down’ BB with a view to axing it altogether?

Brekkie says: June 21, 2009 @ 9:33 pm

Catch up Stu. That’s been very evident for a long while.

Otherwise the alarm bells would have been ringing at C4 just as they were amongst the viewers when the show began failing to hit 3m (heck, even 4m), never mind 2m.

There are even predictions that this weeks late show on Wednesday could fall under the 1m mark.

Stu says: June 21, 2009 @ 9:44 pm

I suppose we’re loyal to the end.

Brekkie says: June 21, 2009 @ 10:40 pm

Well this Wednesdays show is a missed opportunity then. Not even a new twist, but something that’s been done in every series since Hijack, and has never been as effective in practice as it might sound in theory.

trolleyproductions says: June 22, 2009 @ 1:19 am

BB honestly needs help, I think BB 11 would be the time for changing it though, not mid-season.

Chris says: June 22, 2009 @ 8:51 pm

It’s just some of the tasks this year are a bit broing - something simple and effective this year that shocks everyone (and something BB hasnt done in previous years) will change the show, its just hard to think what. Big Brother should play with the housemates’ heads, and go in at night and take stuff from the housemates so they turn against each other - that would be pretty entertaining! Or lock them out of the house for a day or two..something fun :)

Brekkie says: June 22, 2009 @ 10:31 pm

trolley - chances are contract or no contract, there will be no BB11 - or at the very most it will be a very short All Stars season.

With viewing figures so much lower than expected, C4 are probably better off paying any cancellation fees.

Stu says: June 22, 2009 @ 10:38 pm

No, no, no!

julia says: August 6, 2009 @ 3:11 pm

I think we need to get away from making the hms suffer when they lose out on a task. Make the task fun surely someone can think up better task. Why not do endurance task last man standing etc.

There are lots of things they can do. How about putting them into groups and giving them challenges. They are quick but fun to watch wondering who’s going to have the stamina to stay wherever they are supposed to stay and win a luxury food hamper for their group.

There should be a luxury and basic kitchen. A luxury bedroom and bathroom etc. Most of my friends love the chaos and dispute that was caused when there was a luxury bedroom and the rich and poor divide.

Also the jail and the secret tunnel that had all the luxury things for the hms that the other hms thought were suffering. Nothing has to be difficult and just has to be basic so the viewer and hms don’t get bored.

How about a mini shop and each hms have to make a list of the food they want and have a certain ammount of time to do a trolley dash to get there shopping. How about having their own cupboards so they can store their food, that way the greedy ones don’t get away with stealing food.

Cigs and alcohol should be won in a small task each night something for the hms to do. Only hms that have won a certain task should be awarded a party every Saturday night. Anyway you get my drift.

BB needs to offer more its getting a bit boring now. A special sleepover room, pamper rooms, etc. Come on Spice up BB its gone backward instead of forwards.No lve feeds hardly any task or decent task, changing the eviction night etc.

I am not interested in boring z listers pretending to give the evicted hm a peace of their mind. I’d rather watch the old BBBM and listen to the evicted hm it is so boring now.

Leave a comment...
As this is an archive, new comments cannot be added.
bbspy Home E4 Channel 4 Endemol